Kristal Reisinger Part IV: The Underworld

Catfish indirectly admits to being involved in Kristal’s disappearance. The underworld drug scene of Crestone and Moffat gets exposed. A woman is found dead who was involved with dark gothic sexually-explicit films in Crestone.

Be Scofield is a prominent cult reporter whose work is mentioned in the New York Times, Washington Post, People, Daily Beast, The Guardian and has led to coverage on Netflix, Dr. Phil, VICE, CNN and elsewhere.

November 15th, 2021

The most incriminating and significant moment of the Up and Vanished podcast is when Catfish John Keenan responds to host Payne Lindsay who had told him about a guy who messaged asking for $5,000 to reveal what happened to Kristal. Catfish unknowingly admits to having knowledge and information about Kristal’s disappearance.

“I’ve seen a really short video of what they did,” the man tells Payne over Facebook messenger. “I’ll tell you the whole story of what happened, the whole story, because I know what happened for sure. I’ve seen a little video and a voice recording of the last night she was at Catfish’s. I know from what Catfish and…Have told me as well.”

If it wasn’t real information Catfish would have said something to Payne like “I don’t know who that is and I have no idea what he’s talking about,” or “that’s crazy.” Instead, he issued a death threat and says gangsters will be calling the guy to explain himself. Catfish also says he knows that the guy “kills people” and there are “bodies” at his place.